The short answer
Peas and green beans are both legumes, but nutrition guidance treats them differently. In USDA food groups and diabetes meal plans, green peas are a starchy vegetable, grouped with foods such as corn and potatoes. Green beans are a non-starchy vegetable. So when you plan carbohydrates, peas count more like a starch.
Same family, different plants
Green peas are Pisum sativum. Green beans are Phaseolus vulgaris. Both belong to the legume family, Fabaceae, but they are different plants. You also eat them differently:
- Green peas are usually shelled. You eat the small, round seeds and discard the fibrous pods. Edible-pod types, such as snow peas and sugar snap peas, are the exception.
- Green beans are eaten whole, pod and seeds together, while the pods are still young.
They grow differently too. Peas are a cool-season crop that prefers early spring or cooler weather. Beans are a warm-season crop that prefers heat.
Why USDA counts green peas as starchy
USDA MyPlate puts green peas in the starchy vegetables group, along with potatoes, corn and green lima beans. Green beans fall in the other vegetables group, which is where most non-starchy vegetables sit.
Portion guidance in diabetes plans
Diabetes exchange lists give rough portion values:
- Half a cup of cooked peas counts as 1 starch, about 15 g of carbohydrate.
- Half a cup of cooked green beans counts as 1 non-starchy vegetable, about 5 g of carbohydrate.
If you have diabetes or are planning meals for a medical reason, check with your dietitian or care team.
Nutrition per 100 g raw
These are approximate USDA values, rounded.
| Per 100 g, raw | Green peas | Green beans |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | about 81 kcal | about 31 kcal |
| Carbohydrate | about 14.5 g | about 7 g |
| Sugar | about 5.7 g | about 3.3 g |
| Fibre | about 5.1 g | about 2.7 g |
| Protein | about 5.4 g | about 1.8 g |
By weight, peas have roughly three times the protein and about twice the calories and carbohydrate of green beans. Peas are also higher in thiamin, vitamin A, iron and zinc. Green beans are relatively high in vitamin K for the calories they provide.
Are green peas better than broccoli?
They are not an exact swap, so neither one is better in every way. Peas are a starchy vegetable with more protein, carbohydrate and calories. Broccoli is a non-starchy vegetable. If you are cutting back on carbohydrate, non-starchy vegetables such as broccoli or green beans fit more easily. Peas suit a meal where you want some starch and more protein.
Dried peas and lentils
Dried split peas, dried beans and lentils are grouped together in the USDA “beans, peas and lentils” group. MyPlate counts that group as both a vegetable and a protein food. Fresh and frozen green peas are not in this group. They stay with the starchy vegetables.
Cooking each one
- Fresh green peas need about 2 to 4 minutes of boiling or steaming. Frozen peas need about 2 to 3 minutes.
- Green beans take about 5 to 7 minutes to steam to crisp-tender. See how long to steam green beans.
- Cook fresh peas soon after picking. Their sugars turn to starch within hours. Frozen peas are often sweeter than “fresh” peas that have sat on a shelf.
Which one to choose
- For carb planning, green beans are the non-starchy choice. Peas count as a starch.
- For more protein and fibre per 100 g, peas come out ahead.
- For a low-calorie side dish, green beans are a good choice.
Your best choice depends on the rest of your diet. For edible-pod peas, which USDA also classes as non-starchy, see snow peas vs snap peas.