Same species, different names
Yes, lima beans and butter beans are the same species, Phaseolus lunatus. The names come from geography and from the size and maturity of the bean. “Lima” is the usual name in most of the United States, after the city of Lima in Peru. “Butter bean” is the usual name in the UK and in the American South.
Because the names overlap, the same bean can be sold as either one, and labels do not always help. Check the product description, or ask the seller, if size or color matters to your recipe.
Why the names differ
Many cooks use “lima” for young, green, flatter beans and “butter bean” for larger, mature, paler beans. That is a common rule of thumb, but it varies by region and store.
In the American South, “butter beans” often means fresh or frozen limas, including speckled types, not only pale ones. In the UK, butter beans are usually large, flat, creamy-white dried or canned limas.
Two domestications
Lima beans were domesticated twice, once in the Andes of South America, where they produced large seeds, and once in Mesoamerica, where they produced small-seeded types known as sieva. The two lines gave rise to the range of sizes you see today.
Types you will see
- Baby limas are small-seeded types. They are separate varieties, not just young large limas.
- Fordhook is a classic large green lima.
- Christmas lima is a large heirloom with a maroon-mottled seed and a chestnut-like flavor.
- UK dried butter beans are large, flat and creamy white.
Texture and flavor
Lima beans are starchy and creamy, with a buttery texture when cooked. Their skins slip off easily, and the seeds can break apart if overcooked. That softness is why they suit stews, casseroles and purées, and why they can get mushy in long cooking.
Cooking times
- Dried large limas: soak 8 to 12 hours, then simmer gently for about 45 to 60 minutes.
- Dried baby limas: soak, then simmer for about 30 to 45 minutes.
- Frozen baby limas: about 10 minutes of simmering.
- Fresh shelled limas: about 15 to 20 minutes.
Cooking times vary with the age of the beans and the hardness of your water.
Classic dishes
- Succotash: limas cooked with corn, a classic summer side in the US.
- Southern butter beans with ham: slow-simmered with smoked pork for flavor.
- UK butter bean stews and mash: the large dried beans suit thick, creamy dishes.
Greek gigantes are sometimes sold as “giant butter beans,” but they are usually runner beans, not limas. For a look at the very large white beans, see our guide to white beans and navy beans.
Never eat lima beans raw
Lima beans contain cyanogenic glycosides, including linamarin. These compounds can release cyanide when the beans are raw, so never eat them uncooked. Levels vary by variety, and commercial varieties are generally low, but cooking them fully is the rule. Do not eat raw limas.
For a broader look at common beans, see our guide to types of beans. For the parallel question with another bean, see fava and broad beans.