The short answer
No. Navy beans are one type of white bean, but not every white bean is a navy bean. “White beans” is an umbrella term. It covers navy, great northern, cannellini, small white, marrow and baby lima beans, among others. A recipe that calls for white beans can usually use any of them, though size and texture will change the dish.
What “white beans” covers
Navy, great northern, cannellini, small white and marrow beans are all common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris), the same species as kidney and pinto beans. Baby lima is a different species, Phaseolus lunatus. The very large white beans sold as gigante or Corona are usually runner beans (Phaseolus coccineus).
Navy beans
Navy beans are the smallest of the common white beans, about the size of a pea. They are oval or round, and they cook up very soft and creamy. That creaminess makes them the usual choice for soups, purées, dips and baked beans.
The name is often said to come from the US Navy, which served navy beans in its rations in the 1800s. Classic dishes include Boston baked beans, canned baked beans, and US Senate bean soup.
In the UK, navy beans are often sold as haricot beans. “Haricot” is the general French word for bean, so the word alone does not tell you which bean it is. Check the type on the label.
Great northern, cannellini and the rest
Each white bean has its own size and texture:
| Type | Size | Texture when cooked | Simmer time (after soaking) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Navy | Smallest, about pea-sized | Very creamy; breaks down easily | About 45 to 60 minutes |
| Great northern | Medium, oval, slightly flattened | Mild, holds its shape moderately | About 45 to 60 minutes |
| Cannellini (white kidney) | Largest of the common types, kidney-shaped | Creamy inside, holds its shape | About 60 to 90 minutes |
| Baby lima | Small | Starchy and buttery | About 30 to 45 minutes |
Simmer times vary with the age of the beans and the hardness of your water. Old beans take longer.
For more detail on great northern and cannellini, see our great northern vs cannellini comparison. For large and buttery types, see lima beans vs butter beans.
Can you swap them?
Often, yes. In soups and stews, you can swap navy, great northern and cannellini and adjust the cooking time for size. Navy beans can stand in for the others, but they are smaller and creamier, so they will break down more.
The exception is any dish that depends on whole beans, such as a bean salad or pasta e fagioli. There, cannellini or great northern will hold their shape better than navy beans. Canned “white beans” can be any of these types, so check the label.
Common mix-ups
- Flageolet are not white beans. They are pale green beans picked young, and they are common in French cooking.
- Black-eyed peas are not white beans. They are cowpeas with a dark spot on a cream-colored seed.
- Baby lima is a separate variety. It is not just an immature large lima.
- Gigante and Corona are not cannellini. They are usually runner beans and are very large.
For a full list of common bean types, see our guide to types of beans.
Boil dried white beans first
Dried white beans of the common bean species should be soaked, drained and then boiled hard for at least 10 minutes before simmering or slow cooking. Cannellini (white kidney beans) contain about a third of the natural toxin in red kidney beans, so the risk is lower, but the same rule applies. Canned beans are already cooked. For more on this, see why you have to be careful with kidney beans.