Beans stay hard for a few common reasons. They may be old or badly stored, they may have been cooked in hard water, or acid may have gone in too early. Too little time, water or heat also leaves beans underdone. Most of these are fixable. Very old beans sometimes never fully soften.
Old beans and storage
Beans stored for more than about 1 to 2 years can soften slowly or never fully soften. Storage in high heat and humidity firms up the cell walls, and that damage can’t be fully reversed. Buy dried beans from stores with high turnover, and use them within about a year.
Hard water
Calcium and magnesium in hard water strengthen the pectin in bean cell walls, which slows softening. If your water is hard, try filtered or soft water for cooking.
Acid and sugar added too early
Acidic ingredients slow softening when they go in too early. That includes tomatoes, vinegar, wine and lemon. Molasses and brown sugar are acidic and calcium-rich, which is why baked beans hold their shape. Add all of these once the beans are tender.
Not enough time, water or heat
Beans that simmer too gently, or sit in too little water, stay underdone. A slow cooker on low or a bare simmer can leave them firm. Keep the beans covered and keep them simmering. Many “hard” beans just need another 30 to 60 minutes, or more.
High altitude
Water boils at a lower temperature at altitude. At about 5,000 feet (1,500 m), water boils at about 203°F (95°C), so cooking takes much longer. A pressure cooker helps.
How to rescue beans that won’t soften
- Keep simmering. Top up with hot water to keep the beans covered, and give them another 30 to 60 minutes or more. Test as you go.
- Add a little baking soda. About 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon per quart of cooking water raises the pH and can help them soften. Don’t use more, since it can make the beans soapy-tasting and mushy. For more, see why add baking soda when soaking beans.
- Use a pressure cooker. Ten to 20 minutes at high pressure often finishes stubborn beans. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
- Brine next time. Soak the beans in a salt or baking soda brine before cooking. Brining helps hard-to-cook beans, but it doesn’t always fully fix very old ones.
Salt doesn’t cause it
Salt doesn’t make beans hard. It can help soften the skins. If beans stay firm, look at their age, the water and any acid first.
Test several beans
Check several beans from different parts of the pot. Mixed batches cook unevenly, so some beans can be soft while others stay firm.
Common misconceptions
- “Salt makes beans hard.” It softens the skins.
- “Soaking longer will fix very old beans.” It helps little with the hard-to-cook defect.
- “Hard beans mean you cooked them wrong.” Often it’s the age or storage of the beans.
- “All dried beans keep indefinitely.” They’re safe to eat, but they lose cooking quality over time.
Red kidney beans: safety first
Never eat undercooked red kidney beans. Firm beans can still contain active lectins, so boil red kidney beans hard for at least 10 minutes before you cook them further.
Related
For pinto bean times and altitude details, see how long to boil pinto beans. For black beans, see how long to boil black beans from dried. For a slow cooker, see how to cook dried beans in a slow cooker. For the basics, see the cooking dried beans guide.