Aquafaba is the cooking liquid from beans. Chickpea liquid is the usual benchmark, but several other beans make foam that works in baking and cooking. This guide covers which bean liquids perform best, how to get the right thickness, and where aquafaba falls short.
Can you make aquafaba from other beans?
Yes. Most beans’ cooking or canning liquid can be used, but results vary a lot. The liquid holds proteins, saponins and starches that let it foam and emulsify. Bean type, brand and how concentrated the liquid is all change how well it whips.
Which bean liquids work best?
| Bean liquid | What to expect |
|---|---|
| Chickpea | Neutral flavor and color, and the most reliable foam. |
| White beans (cannellini, navy, great northern) | Pale and mild. The best alternatives to chickpea, and they whip well. |
| Butter (lima) and white kidney | Often work in tests, though results vary by brand. |
| Black bean | Whips, but it’s grey-purple and tastes of beans. Suits brownies and dark cakes, not meringue. |
| Red kidney and pinto | Works for binding, but the color and flavor carry through. |
| Yellow split pea and soybean | Has foamed in published comparisons; home results vary. |
| Lentil | Usually too thin or murky. Results are unreliable. |
Egg swap ratios
Use these as starting points:
- 3 tablespoons aquafaba = 1 whole egg
- 2 tablespoons aquafaba = 1 egg white
- 1 tablespoon aquafaba = 1 egg yolk (approximate)
Getting the right thickness
Good aquafaba should feel like raw egg white. If yours is thin, simmer it down by about a third to a half until it thickens. Liquid from cooking beans in minimal water, or in a pressure cooker, is usually thick enough once it’s chilled.
Unsalted or low-sodium canned liquid gives you more control. Salted liquid can taste off in sweet recipes.
Whipping and stabilizing
Whip it in a stand mixer for 3 to 10 minutes, until it forms stiff peaks. Add 1/4 teaspoon of cream of tartar per about 1/2 cup of liquid to help it hold its shape.
Is the liquid from canned chickpeas healthy?
We don’t have reliable nutrition data for aquafaba, so this guide doesn’t make health claims about it. Canned chickpea liquid is mostly water, with some dissolved starch and protein, and it’s salted. If sodium matters to you, choose unsalted or low-sodium cans. For more on the cans themselves, see do I have to cook garbanzo beans from a can.
Where aquafaba falls short
Aquafaba doesn’t replace eggs one-for-one in everything. It struggles where the egg’s structure matters most, such as custards and egg-heavy cakes. Stick with recipes that use it for whipping or binding.
Common misconceptions
- “Only chickpea liquid works.” Several white beans perform close to it.
- “All bean liquids behave the same.” Foaming varies widely by bean, brand and concentration.
- “Aquafaba replaces eggs one-for-one in everything.” It doesn’t. Custards and egg-heavy cakes are a poor fit.
- “Black bean aquafaba is unusable.” It’s fine where color doesn’t matter.
For the chickpea liquid specifically, see dried to canned chickpeas, which covers reducing the cooking liquid.
Storage
Aquafaba keeps about 3 to 5 days in the fridge. Freeze it in ice cube trays for up to about 3 months, then thaw cubes as you need them.
Safety
Use liquid only from fully cooked or canned beans. Never use liquid from soaking raw kidney beans. Raw kidney beans contain a natural toxin that a hard boil destroys.