Edamame and Soybeans

Edamame vs Soybeans: Are They the Same Bean?

Edamame and dry soybeans are the same species. Learn how harvest stage changes their nutrition, texture and cooking time, and which one to buy.

On this page
  1. Short answer: same species, different harvest
  2. How edamame and dry soybeans differ
  3. Terms that cause confusion
  4. Edamame vs dry soybeans at a glance
  5. Nutrition: compare cooked with cooked
  6. Cooking time and method
  7. Are edamame beans the same as shelled soybeans?
  8. Which is healthier, edamame or soybeans?
  9. Which should you buy?
  10. Allergy and safety

Short answer: same species, different harvest

Edamame and dry soybeans are the same species, Glycine max. Edamame is the name for soybeans picked while they are still young and green. Dry soybeans are the same crop left on the plant until the pods brown and the seeds harden. The Japanese name edamame means “branch bean,” because the pods are often sold still attached to the stalk.

So the difference comes mainly from harvest stage and variety, not from a separate kind of bean. That changes how each one tastes, how it feels to eat, and how long it takes to cook.

How edamame and dry soybeans differ

Growers pick edamame when the seeds fill most of the pod, roughly 80 to 90 percent of the cavity, and the pod is still bright green. The window is short, often only days. Once the pods start to yellow, the beans are past the edamame stage and their sweetness falls. That short window is one reason most people buy edamame frozen rather than fresh.

Dry soybeans stay on the plant until they dry down to low moisture, which lets them be stored for long periods.

Most edamame comes from vegetable-type varieties bred for large, mild, sweet seeds. Grain-type soybeans, the ones used for oil, tofu and animal feed, are generally smaller and can taste more “beany.”

Terms that cause confusion

  • Edamame: the young, green soybean, usually cooked in the pod or shelled.
  • Mukimame: shelled edamame. It is not a separate bean.
  • Green soybeans: this phrase usually means edamame, but it can also mean mature green-seeded soybeans, such as the Japanese aodaizu, which are harvested dry. Check the label or ask the seller if it matters for your recipe.

For the other beans and pods that look like edamame, see types of edamame and beans that look like edamame.

Edamame vs dry soybeans at a glance

Edamame Dry (mature) soybeans
Harvest Picked young, pods still green Dried on the plant, pods brown
Texture Tender, with a slight bite Firm, dense and meaty
Flavor Mildly sweet, grassy and buttery Nutty and starchy
Before cooking Usually cooked from frozen or fresh Soak 8 to 12 hours
Cooking time About 3 to 5 minutes in boiling water Often 2 to 4 hours of simmering
Common uses Snacks, salads, stir-fries, grain bowls Soups, stews, tofu, soy milk, miso
Typical forms Fresh or frozen, in the pod or shelled Dry in bags, or canned cooked

Nutrition: compare cooked with cooked

Dry soybeans have not absorbed water yet, so their numbers look much larger than what you would eat. For a fair comparison, put cooked beans on both sides.

Per 100 g of cooked edamame (frozen, prepared), USDA-based values are about 121 calories, 11.9 g protein, 5.2 g fat, 8.9 g carbohydrate and 5.2 g fiber. Edamame is also high in folate, at about 311 micrograms per 100 g, and it provides vitamin C.

Cooked mature soybeans have more protein, fat and iron per 100 g, and a little more fiber. Edamame has far more folate and more vitamin C, and it has fewer calories. Sources differ on the exact figures for mature soybeans, so check the database entry you use before you compare.

Cooking time and method

Edamame cooks in minutes. Boil the pods or shelled beans in salted water for about 3 to 5 minutes, or steam them for about 5 minutes, then drain. For the full methods, see how to cook frozen edamame.

Dry soybeans need planning. Soak them for 8 to 12 hours in three to four times their volume of cold water. Drain, cover with fresh water by about 2 inches (5 cm), then simmer partly covered for about 2 to 4 hours, until tender. Soybeans foam as they cook, so use a large pot and skim the foam during the first 10 to 15 minutes. A pressure cooker shortens the time a lot. The full steps are in how to cook dried soybeans.

Are edamame beans the same as shelled soybeans?

In a botanical sense, yes: edamame is a soybean. In the store, though, “shelled soybeans” usually means dry, mature beans that need soaking and long cooking. Shelled edamame is the young green bean taken out of the pod. The two behave very differently in a recipe, so do not swap one for the other without adjusting the cooking time.

Which is healthier, edamame or soybeans?

Neither is better across the board. Cooked mature soybeans give more protein and iron per 100 g, while edamame gives more folate and vitamin C and fewer calories. The better choice depends on what you are making and what you need from it.

If you are choosing between edamame and green beans, see edamame vs green beans.

Which should you buy?

  • Snack or appetizer: edamame. It cooks in minutes and works warm or cold.
  • Homemade tofu or soy milk: dry soybeans. Both start from soaked mature beans.
  • Soups and stews that simmer for hours: dry soybeans, which hold their shape better.
  • Quick salad or fried rice: shelled frozen edamame, which needs only a short boil or thaw.

When buying frozen edamame, look for loose, bright-green pods with no large ice clumps, and check the label for added salt or sauce. For dry soybeans, choose whole, evenly colored beans and skip bags with many cracked or shriveled ones.

Allergy and safety

  • Soy allergy: Soy is one of the major food allergens in the United States. Edamame is not “less soy” than dry soybeans. It carries the same allergen proteins, so people with a soy allergy should avoid both.
  • Cook both: Raw soybeans contain trypsin inhibitors and lectins that interfere with digestion. Cooking largely inactivates them, so edamame should not be eaten raw. See can edamame be eaten raw?

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →