What counts as a type of edamame?
All edamame is Glycine max, the same species as soybeans. “Types” of edamame means cultivars (named varieties) and seed color, not separate beans. Most edamame sold in stores is green-seeded, which is the standard commercial type.
Green, black and brown edamame
- Green-seeded: the everyday type, with bright green beans and a mild, sweet flavor. Most frozen edamame is green-seeded.
- Black-seeded: immature black soybeans, such as tamba kuromame from Hyogo, Japan. They are harvested green in autumn. Their color is natural, not dye.
- Brown-seeded: heirloom types from Yamagata, Japan, such as chamame and dadachamame, are often described as nutty, with a popcorn-like aroma.
Named varieties for home gardeners
US home gardeners often grow named cultivars such as ‘Envy’, ‘Midori Giant’, ‘Butterbean’ and ‘Shirofumi’. Days to harvest vary by source and climate, so check the seed packet for your area. Vegetable cultivars usually hold two or three seeds per pod.
Market forms
Edamame comes in several forms:
- fresh, on the stalk
- fresh pods, where available
- frozen in the pod
- frozen shelled, also called mukimame
- dry-roasted or seasoned snacks
Mukimame is not a separate bean. It is edamame with the pods removed. Dry-roasted snacks are cooked, so they are ready to eat as they are.
Beans that look like edamame
Several pods and beans look similar at a glance. None of them is a kind of edamame.
- Fava beans (broad beans): much larger, with flat pods. Each bean has a tough skin, usually removed after blanching. Fava beans can cause a serious reaction called favism in people with G6PD deficiency.
- Lima beans: flat, kidney-shaped and pale green, in smooth, flat pods. Raw lima beans contain compounds that can release cyanide, so always cook them.
- Green peas: round, smaller and sweeter, in smooth pods.
- Fresh green chickpeas: puffy pods holding one or two seeds each.
- Fresh black-eyed or field peas: pale beans with a visible dark “eye.”
- Mung beans: tiny and green when dried, and in long, thin pods when fresh.
Quick visual checks
- Edamame pods are fuzzy, with fine hairs. Most lookalike pods are smooth.
- Edamame pods are short and plump, with two or three beans that bulge inside.
- Green bean pods are long and slender, with small, undeveloped seeds.
Common misconceptions
- Black or brown edamame is not a different plant, and it is not dyed.
- Lima beans, fava beans and peas are not types of edamame.
- Mukimame is not a separate bean. It is shelled edamame.
- Grain soybeans picked green are not the same as vegetable-type edamame. They are smaller and often more “beany” in flavor.
Safety
- Soy is a major allergen in every color and type of edamame.
- Cook edamame before eating. Raw soybeans contain trypsin inhibitors and lectins that interfere with digestion.
- Always cook raw lima beans, which contain compounds that can release cyanide.
- If you have G6PD deficiency, check with your doctor before eating fava beans.