Different plants, similar pods
Edamame and green beans are both legumes, but they belong to different genera. Edamame is an immature soybean, Glycine max. Green beans are the young pods of the common bean, Phaseolus vulgaris. You eat the beans inside an edamame pod, but you eat the whole green bean pod.
Both are green, both grow in pods, and both are sold fresh and frozen, so they are easy to mix up. Edamame pods are short and fuzzy, with two or three bulging beans. Green bean pods are long and smooth, with small, undeveloped seeds.
How they taste and feel to eat
Edamame has a mildly sweet, nutty, buttery taste and a tender bite. Green beans have a crisp, fresh taste when lightly cooked, and they soften as they cook longer.
Nutrition per 100 g
Green beans are shown raw, since that is the standard reference value. Cooking changes these numbers somewhat. Values are approximate.
| Per 100 g | Edamame (cooked, frozen) | Green beans (raw) |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | about 121 | about 31 |
| Protein | about 11.9 g | about 1.8 g |
| Fat | about 5.2 g | about 0.2 g |
| Carbohydrate | about 8.9 g | about 7 g |
| Fiber | about 5.2 g | about 2.7 g |
| Folate | about 311 µg | about 33 µg |
| Vitamin C | about 6 mg | about 12 mg |
Edamame has roughly six to seven times the protein of green beans per 100 g. Its folate is about nine times higher. Green beans have more vitamin C, and they are far lower in calories.
Are green beans the same as edamame?
No. Green beans are not immature soybeans, and edamame is not a green bean. Both are legumes and both come in green pods, but they are different genera, with different seeds and different nutrition.
Are green soybeans healthy?
“Green soybeans” is a confusing term. In stores it usually means edamame, the young green soybean. Some people use it for mature green-seeded soybeans, which are a different crop and are harvested dry.
Cooked edamame is a good source of plant protein, fiber and folate, and it fits well into a varied diet. It is also more calorie-dense than most vegetables, so portion size matters if you are watching calories. Whether it is “healthy” depends mostly on the rest of your diet.
What is better for you, green beans or edamame?
It depends on your goal:
- Protein, fiber and folate: edamame.
- Fewer calories and more vitamin C: green beans.
Both can be part of a balanced diet, and many people eat both.
How to cook each
- Edamame: boil in salted water or steam for about 3 to 5 minutes, then drain. Squeeze the beans out of the pods. For frozen edamame, see how to cook frozen edamame.
- Green beans: boil or steam for about 4 to 7 minutes. For salads or freezing, blanch for 2 to 3 minutes and cool quickly in ice water.
Cook green beans before eating. Raw beans contain a lectin, and cooking reduces it. Edamame must also be cooked, as explained in can edamame be eaten raw?
Allergy and labeling
Edamame is soy, one of the major food allergens in the United States. Green beans are not soy. Read labels on processed foods, because soy can appear as an ingredient in sauces and seasonings, and some products made on shared equipment carry soy warnings.
For more on protein, see is edamame a complete protein?