Two plant groups
Adzuki beans (Vigna angularis) are a different genus from kidney and pinto beans. Kidney and pinto beans are both common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris), the same species as most dried beans sold in US stores. Because they are the same species, they behave similarly in the pot. Adzuki behaves differently.
For a wider look at the common bean types, see our guide to types of beans.
Size, shape and color
| Adzuki | Kidney | Pinto | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Size | Small, about 5 mm long | Large | Medium |
| Shape | Small oval | Kidney-shaped | Oval |
| Color | Deep red, with a thin white line along one side | Dark red or light red | Beige with brown speckles |
Pinto beans lose their speckles when cooked and turn a fairly uniform brown or pinkish-brown.
Taste and texture
Adzuki is mild, slightly sweet and nutty. Cooked, it is soft and creamy. It is the bean of choice for sweet dishes in East Asian cooking, which is why people cook it for its taste, not just as a filler.
Kidney beans have thick skins and firm flesh. They hold their shape through long cooking, so they suit chili and stews where you want whole beans.
Pinto beans have thin skins and a soft, creamy interior. They taste earthy and mash easily. The skin is slightly chewy even when the beans are well cooked.
So no, pinto and kidney beans do not taste or feel the same. Pinto is creamier and more earthy. Kidney is firmer and holds its shape.
Cooking times and soaking
Cooking time varies with the age and dryness of the beans, and older stock takes longer.
| Soak before cooking? | Simmer time (after soaking) | |
|---|---|---|
| Adzuki | Not needed | About 45 to 60 minutes (about 60 to 90 minutes unsoaked) |
| Kidney | Helpful, 8 to 12 hours | About 60 to 90 minutes, after boiling hard (see below) |
| Pinto | Helpful, 8 to 12 hours | About 60 to 90 minutes |
Adzuki is the easiest of the three because it does not need soaking. For kidney and pinto beans, plan ahead with an overnight soak.
Uses in cooking
- Adzuki: sweetened red bean paste (anko) for desserts and sweets, red bean soup, and sekihan, rice cooked with adzuki beans for celebrations. Adzuki also appears in savory soups and grain bowls.
- Kidney: chili, soups, red beans and rice, and rajma, the Hindi name for kidney beans and the curry made from them.
- Pinto: refried beans, charro beans, burritos and chili.
Can you swap them?
- Kidney for pinto: Yes, 1 to 1 in chili, soups and stews. Kidney stays firm and holds its shape, while pinto turns creamier and thickens the dish.
- Pinto for kidney: Also works in the same dishes, but expect a softer, creamier result.
- Cannellini (white kidney beans) for pinto: Both are creamy, but cannellini is milder and holds its shape better, while pinto is earthier. For more on cannellini and other white beans, see our guide to white beans and navy beans.
- Adzuki: Small red beans or kidney beans work in savory dishes. There is no good swap for anko, because its flavor and texture come from adzuki.
Nutrition and health
Per cooked cup, approximate USDA-style values:
| Per cooked cup (approx.) | Adzuki | Kidney | Pinto |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calories | about 290 | about 225 | about 245 |
| Protein | about 17 g | about 15 g | about 15 g |
| Fiber | about 17 g | about 11 g | about 15 g |
All three are good sources of protein and fiber, and adzuki is a useful source of folate. Red kidney beans are nutritious, but no single bean is a cure-all, so a mix of beans is a sensible approach. US guidelines count beans as both a protein food and a vegetable, which is covered in our note on whether beans are considered vegetables.
Kidney beans need a proper boil
Raw or undercooked red kidney beans contain a natural toxin called phytohaemagglutinin, which is destroyed by boiling. To be safe, soak dried kidney beans, discard the soaking water, then boil them hard for at least 10 minutes before simmering. Slow cookers on low may not get hot enough, so boil first and then slow cook. Canned kidney beans are already cooked and do not need the boil. Pinto and other common beans also contain this compound in smaller amounts, so the same boil is a sensible habit.
For more detail, see why you have to be careful with kidney beans.