Mash some beans, then simmer uncovered
Short answer: mash ¼ to 1 cup of cooked beans against the side of the pot and stir them back in. Then simmer uncovered for 10 to 20 minutes to reduce the extra liquid.
Wait 10 to 15 minutes before judging the thickness. Bean starch keeps thickening as the pot cools.
Blend part of the beans
If you prefer a smoother pot, blend about 1 cup of beans with some of the liquid and return the mixture to the pot. Stir it in and simmer for a few minutes.
Use the bean cooking liquid, not water
When you need more liquid, use the starchy liquid from cooking the beans rather than plain water. It carries starch that helps thicken the pot.
Simmer long enough for red beans to cream
Red beans become creamy with a long, slow simmer, about 2 hours or more. The beans break down and the sauce thickens. Stir often over low heat, because thickened beans scorch easily.
Quick fixes with starch
Cornstarch slurry. Whisk 1 tablespoon of cornstarch into 2 tablespoons of cold water. Stir it into about 2 cups of liquid and simmer for 1 to 2 minutes until glossy. Use cold water so the cornstarch dissolves without lumps.
Masa harina. Whisk in 1 to 2 tablespoons and simmer for at least 5 minutes. It suits Latin-style beans and gives a slightly corn-flavored thickness.
Instant potato flakes. Add 1 to 2 tablespoons at a time. They thicken almost instantly, so add them slowly.
Flour. Flour needs to be cooked to lose its raw taste. Cook it in a roux, or simmer it for at least 5 minutes. Raw flour dropped straight into the pot lumps and tastes pasty.
Potato or calabaza
A cubed potato or calabaza (West Indian pumpkin) breaks down in the pot and thickens the stew. This is the method used for Puerto Rican habichuelas. See arroz con habichuelas for how it is used there.
Rice can thicken the beans too
If you are cooking rice in the same pot as the beans, stirring the cooked rice in absorbs liquid. Add the rice gradually, a little at a time, and check the texture as you go.
What not to do
- Covered simmering. Cooking longer with the lid on will not fix watery beans. Uncover the pot to let liquid evaporate.
- Raw flour. It lumps and tastes pasty.
- Baking soda. It changes the flavor and can alter the nutrition of the beans. Do not use it as a thickener.
Thinning leftovers
Leftover beans thicken in the fridge overnight. When you reheat them, add a splash of water or stock and warm them gently over low heat.
For a creamy red beans and rice, see Louisiana red beans and rice. For the full cluster overview, see rice and beans: classic pairings, nutrition and carbs.